Tesoro D'italia - Pleasantville

Great appetizers. especially the calamari, great atmosphere and amazing service! our waitress katelyn (sp was tight and always so attentive! highly recommend tesoro D’Italia!

Going out for dinner and spending 3 times (or 300 more for food then making it better at home; your expectations for fine dining should be high.Unfortunately, the food here was bland for both my wife and I. It’s not worth the money or time to get there.I gave the waiter manager an opportunity to make things right and they chose not to discount the meal hence leading me to write this review.Always, follow the golden rule (don’t be nice) if you don’t like the food return it immediately and ask for something else. If you don’t like that send it back and leave.There’s a lot of restaurants in our area to choose from so skip this place all together.

The staff quite friendly and very accommodating. Dinner portions are large enough for two and come with house salad. So expect to take some home. The prices are a little high but no bad for quality and portion size.

This previously catering focused venue has been transformed into a great addition to the local dining scene. Completely remodeled. Nice ambience. Food and service were both great.

The Ambience Decor are very pretty,! It was my Birthday expected much more from this place since I saw some great reviews. I was disappointed with the salad. I got mostly an iceberg salad my friend got a mixed green salad. I didn't understand why I didn't get mixed green salad ugh! I ordered Lobster Risotto, at first it was hot tasty. After a few mins, I realized it was all risotto mushrooms, very small portions of lobster bits! The waiter promised it would have great chunks of Lobster in it. The waiter did go back into the kitchen put a little bit more. It was still not fresh chunky lobster! I really didn't want all that risotto either! Loved mushroom in it. Broccoli Rabe was missing the sauteed garlic. It came out plain. I told waiter this, he brought it back to kitchen now it was overly doused with olive oil...a tad bit of sauteed garlic. There was just not enough sauteed garlic!!! I get the vanilla ice cream gelato cold chocolate syrup when I ask for hot fudge! I was surprised that the restaurant charged $12 for this. I have eaten the same dessert at other places, usually no more than $6-8. I didn't even get a birthday wish or candle on it. This was my first time ever at this Restaurant. I do like good portions,not skimpy. I'm disappointed in lack of service in celebration of my Birthday as well as the food was just not what I expected! My friend had the lobster ravioli with cream sauce, that was excellent. But it doesn't come with vegetable! To peter yes I have given some great reviews. Wow you are very disrespectful not forthcoming or polite! . I will make sure to never go back.