Don Juan - Pleasantville

This review started out as a 4.5 stars from walking through the door then as we left went to a 3.4 star rating. For Cinco de Mayo holiday afternoon, seemed at a normal capacity because there was no wait time to be seated which was a total plus for us to get a drink and snacks. The food was fresh, packed with flavor and a solid portion. We ordered the ceviche and chicken nachos as appetizers, they were a way bit overpriced (I understand it's NY prices but damn for apps). We also got a margarita and couple of beers but the sad thing is there was supposed to be a second margarita that we never got. It took quite a while to get our servers attention and we understand it's a holiday with the possibility of shorthanded servers. We had two servers in the back dining area and about 4 runners that could've gotten our items while she was busy. That was the main reason for the decrease in rating, LOUD music where I had to scream to talk and charging us for the missing marg. Overall, we will come back because the food was fantastic and in hopes the service will be better.

Authentic Mexican restaurant that gives all the feels you're looking for ! Service is spectacular and servers are super attentive. Complimentary chips and salsa for the table with a generous amount of salsa. We ordered quesabirria tacos for apps which comes with three dipping sauces bursting with flavor. I ordered steak fajitas. Steak was cooked to perfection and portion size was great. I would 100% recommend this place and will for sure be coming back.

We found ourselves in Pleasantville the other day and stumbled on the Mexican spot. I remember this place being a nice Italian restaurant years ago and when I saw it was a Mexican restaurant now, I had to get my taco fix on. Decore is very cool, staff was friendly, and the food was very good. I was disappointed by a very limited wine selection but a nice sangria eased my pain. Definitely a nice addition to a great little town. Enjoy!

The shrimp isn't properly de-veined, the steak is an obliterated overcooked brick, the beans are a runny sludge, the chips are stale and unseasoned, the salsa is devoid of any flavor, and the churros are break-your-teeth rock hard. Don Juan is extremely expensive for exceedingly below-average food.

The guacamole was great. And the drinks were dynamic. Alex the bartender Knows what he's doing. The decor was awesome. Very nice and welcoming feeel