Reviews
What Stephen Kim doesn't like about Osteria Cotta:
The food is probably way better in person. I assume that the service is great as well as the atmosphere but the food was very poor when it was delivered. Even though I live down the block from this restaurant , the delivery aspect of it ruined the entire meal. I highly recommend eating there than delivery.Food: 2/5 View all feedback. What Mella likes about Osteria Cotta:
Love this place so much! Reasonably priced, yummy food. We got the fried calamari, margarita pizza, and spaghetti. Great service and awesome outdoor seating!! Will keep coming back! View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The service was excellent and good was great. We'll be back.
We just ordered two pizzas and a side vegetables. Let me discuss this by making our own pizzas at home with a stone in the oven. We've asked for thin and crisp....
read moreCame to Cotta to brunch to celebrate a 100 miles race of a friend and we could not be better treated!!! Steve and Saxon took care of us and the food was delicio...
read moreThis upper western restaurant is the perfect meeting place for friends. Large bar and ambience melt the pasta in your mouth.
This is a lovely restaurant. The waitress and all staff were very welcoming and professional. Food was very good. We ate here before going to Shakespeare-in-the...
read moreOsteria Cotta, located on the Upper West Side, offers a mix of experiences according to various reviews. While some customers rave about the delicious food and impeccable vibes, others were disappointed by the delivery service. The restaurant seems to excel in its in-house dining experience, with highlights such as the Fettuccine Carbonara and the Baked Eggs in Purgatory. The atmosphere is praised as cool and relaxed, with great service to match. For those seeking a boozy brunch or a tasty Italian meal, this restaurant seems to be a solid choice. However, potential guests should be aware that the lack of air conditioning for more than half of the seating may pose a challenge during hot summer days. Overall, Osteria Cotta appears to be a gem for those looking for quality Italian cuisine at reasonable prices in a stylish setting.
One of my absolutely favorite bottomless brunch spots in the city! Have been here dozens of times and never had a bad experience. 10/10 recommend. Very affordab...
read moreThe food is probably way better in person. I assume that the service is great as well as the atmosphere but the food was very poor when it was delivered. Even t...
read moreDelicious food at a good value, especially versus what you typically find in Manhattan. Pasta tasted fresh, great arugula salad and burrata. Only downside was s...
read moreGreat Italian restaurant with fair pricing and great service. The ambiance is fun and romantic. The food selection is diverse and a great list of drinks. Affoga...
read moreThis was a great find. The food and drinks were excellent and the prices were an amazing value by Manhattan standards, with most entrees under $25. Even the win...
read moreLove this place so much! Reasonably priced, yummy food. We got the fried calamari, margarita pizza, and spaghetti. Great service and awesome outdoor seating!! W...
read moreOsteria Cotta has to be one of the best brunch spots I’ve been to. Great food, strong drinks and impeccable vibes. I had a fairly large party for bottomless bru...
read moreI come here a lot and never realized there was an upstairs. This place is great for a group, a date, a fun time, with kids, you name it and there is a spot here...
read moreThe brunch was very good. The Baked Eggs in Purgatory were delicious- I had never had before, but it was warm, fluffy, and delicious. The restaurant is very coo...
read moreMet w friends here 4 the holidays, and had a delightful brunch! Delicious food, very good service.
The wood fired wings are so flavorful and juicy every time we order them! I highly recommend!
Amatriciana pizza had way too much red sauce. The wings were fine, not grilled just cooked. Linguini wasn't good quality pasta. I can make better at home!
Great wings The pizza was delicious and I love the wings. Highly recommended.
Delicious! I highly recommend it.
The tartufo pizza and rosemary wings are divine!!
This restaurant is a lovely European-style spot with a simple yet beautiful atmosphere. The Italian food is very delicious, and the pizza is authentic. The pric...
read moreOsteria Cotta offers a lovely atmosphere with distinctive soft lighting. The food is exceptional, especially the wood-fired rosemary wings which are the best I...
read moreI visited this restaurant on a Saturday for lunch. They offered an enticing all-you-can-drink cocktail option, where you pay a set price for an entree and have...
read moreExceptional food (the paparadelle with braised pork was delicious) and good service. The atmosphere is incredible, with beautiful decor and cozy lighting and fu...
read moreDinnee time, ourside seating. Got the meatballs to start with some bread and oliveoil, pizza and lasagna. Portions were approriate for the price, specially the...
read moreThe service was excellent and good was great. We will be back.
We just ordered two pizzas and a side vegetable. Let me preface this by saying we make our own pizzas at home with a stone in the oven. We asked for thin and cr...
read moreCame to Cotta for brunch to celebrate a friend's 100 mile race and we could not have been treated better!!! Steve and Saxon took the best care of us, and the fo...
read moreThis upper west side restaurant is the perfect meeting place for friends. Great bar and ambiance the pasta melts in your mouth.
Ana is the best of the best! She's been my server twice and I adore her! She's always so attentive and she makes eating here fun! The food is always great....
The food was fantastic, service was amazing, everyone was attentive and looked after me well. I loved their out door seating. Shannon was so kind and made...
It's been a while since I've wrote a positive review but the server behind the bar was a pleasure! Lasagna? great. Martinis? great. Service? great! Thanks...