Osteria Cotta - New York

Italian, Pizza, Pasta
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Osteria Cotta.

Osteria Cotta

Osteria Cotta
4.3 / 5 (8573 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Osteria Cotta from New York contains about 134 different menus and drinks. On average you pay about $12.7 for a dish / drink.

Osteria Cotta, located on the Upper West Side, offers a mix of experiences according to various reviews. While some customers rave about the delicious food and impeccable vibes, others were disappointed by the delivery service. The restaurant seems to excel in its in-house dining experience, with highlights such as the Fettuccine Carbonara and the Baked Eggs in Purgatory. The atmosphere is praised as cool and relaxed, with great service to match. For those seeking a boozy brunch or a tasty Italian meal, this restaurant seems to be a solid choice. However, potential guests should be aware that the lack of air conditioning for more than half of the seating may pose a challenge during hot summer days. Overall, Osteria Cotta appears to be a gem for those looking for quality Italian cuisine at reasonable prices in a stylish setting.

Last update: 23.01.2026 from: Opentable

Images

Osteria Cotta Food Osteria Cotta Food Osteria Cotta Inside Osteria Cotta Food Osteria Cotta Menu Osteria Cotta Food Osteria Cotta Food Osteria Cotta Food

Reservation request for Osteria Cotta

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 8573 reviews

Was Mella at Osteria Cotta a mag?
I absolutely adore this place! The prices are reasonable, and the food is delicious. We ordered the fried calamari, margherita pizza, and spaghetti, and everything was fantastic. The service was excellent, and the outdoor seating is wonderful! I will definitely be returning! View all feedback.

What Stephen Kim dislikes about Osteria Cotta:
The food is likely much better when enjoyed in person. I imagine that the service and ambiance are also wonderful, but the quality of the food I received through delivery was disappointing. Despite living just down the street from the restaurant, the delivery experience spoiled the entire meal for me. I strongly recommend dining in rather than opting for delivery. Food rating: 2/5. View all feedback.

jose-sosa-rueda
07.02.2024

Dinnee time, ourside seating. Got the meatballs to start with some bread and oliveoil, pizza and lasagna. Portions were approriate for the price, specially the meatballs which were 5 , with plenty of sause and parmesan cheese. The saus was saltyfor sure, as it was present in the lasagna and pizza as well but it could be subjective on our part . Service was good, andattentive.

moxa
07.02.2024

This restaurant is a lovely European-style spot with a simple yet beautiful atmosphere. The Italian food is very delicious, and the pizza is authentic. The prices are excellent, especially for drinks. I definitely recommend it.

duncan
17.10.2024

This upper west side restaurant is the perfect meeting place for friends. Great bar and ambiance the pasta melts in your mouth.

opentable-diner-181
17.10.2024

The service was outstanding and the food was fantastic. We definitely plan to return!

ellas
17.10.2024

I visited Cotta for brunch to celebrate a friend's 100-mile race, and we were treated exceptionally well! Steve and Saxon provided us with outstanding service, and the food was incredibly delicious. The brunch specials and drinks were fantastic as well! The atmosphere was pleasant and lovely, making for a wonderful experience. I highly recommend Cotta to everyone!

  • Small Plates

    Meatballs In Tomato
    Meatballs In Tomato
    $9.9
  • Eggs

    Baked Truffle Eggs
    Baked Truffle Eggs
    $12.9
  • Antipasti - Verdure / Vegetables

    Beets Pecorino
    Beets Pecorino
    $5.0
  • Pasta

    Fusilli Piselli
    Fusilli Piselli
    $13.9
    Farmhouse Lasagne
    Farmhouse Lasagne
    $15.9
  • Secondi

    Wood Fire Free-Range Chicken
    Wood Fire Free-Range Chicken
    $19.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.