Legacy Pizza Bakery - New Albany

I decided to try this restaurant for the first time during my lunch break, and I was pleasantly surprised! The calzone I ordered was one of the best I've ever had. They even have a special deal on Tuesdays where you can get a dollar off. Madison, our server, was very friendly and helpful. I can't wait to come back and try more items on their menu. I also appreciated how quickly my freshly cooked meal was served to me, just 15 minutes after I arrived. If you're in a rush, don't hesitate to stop by this restaurant.

Wow, this restaurant is a hidden gem! I visit New Albany frequently from Nashville and I have never had a bad meal here. I have tried the calzone, pizza, and two different sandwiches on my visits and I would give all of them a 5-star rating. The service can be a bit slow, but the food is absolutely fantastic!

I discovered a hidden gem of a restaurant! It is clear that the owners have poured their heart and soul into this establishment. The New York-style pizza is phenomenal, a true work of art. For those living near New Albany, there is no need to ever settle for chain pizza again. The value, service, and atmosphere are all top-notch. In today's economy, it is well worth investing in a place like this.

This is the finest pizza we've had in 25 years, the Classic, the Bacon Jam and Meat Lovers. Also outrageously good are the calzones, exploding with cheese, and the strombolis, and the meatball subs, and the cookies. And the breads! I would go there weekly just for the homemade breads, sub rolls, wonderful French baquettes and bialies. Since first going to Legacy, I have to buy there at least weekly, and sometimes twice or more, and I still haven't explored the entire menu. Go there.

Love this place so much. I can't believe I haven't written a review of it yet. I just had a slice of tomato pie from Legacy last night, and it was incredible. I'm ordering a whole pie this week. Their whole wheat bread is delicious, and has become a staple of my diet. Their pizza is great, as well as their subs, and spaghetti squash, and all of their baked goods. Wonderful, friendly people as well. This is exactly the kind of small business that everyone needs to support.