Reviews
What Matt L likes about Middletown Pizza:
Decent pizza for reasonable prices, I feel like they go a little light on the sauce but other than that its pretty good. Their prices are more affordable compared to other places around View all feedback. What Christina H doesn't like about Middletown Pizza:
Very disappointed in the NY style pizza. The crust was possibly a premade crust kinda like a cracker crust. Very strange. The sauce and toppings were good but that crust was horrible. We paid over $60 for a pizza, a Greek salad and a small order of chicken bites. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Decent pizza for reasonable prices, I feel like they go a little light on the sauce but other than that its pretty good. Their prices are more affordable compar...
read moreVery disappointed in the NY style pizza. The crust was possibly a premade crust kinda like a cracker crust. Very strange. The sauce and toppings were good but t...
read moreWe ordered 2 extra large pizzas and they were excellent. The ordering process was easy and the people are awesome. We will order from them again.
I asked for no gorgonzola cheese but it was there, and I cannot eat it so I had to pick it out and was very difficult to get all the pieces out.
Fries were hot and good. cheessteak was good
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more