Images
Contribute
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Matt L likes about Middletown Pizza:
Decent pizza for reasonable prices, I feel like they go a little light on the sauce but other than that its pretty good. Their prices are more affordable compared to other places around View all feedback.
What Christina H doesn't like about Middletown Pizza:
Very disappointed in the NY style pizza. The crust was possibly a premade crust kinda like a cracker crust. Very strange. The sauce and toppings were good but that crust was horrible. We paid over $60 for a pizza, a Greek salad and a small order of chicken bites. View all feedback.
Decent pizza for reasonable prices, I feel like they go a little light on the sauce but other than that its pretty good. Their prices are more affordable compared to other places around
Very disappointed in the NY style pizza. The crust was possibly a premade crust kinda like a cracker crust. Very strange. The sauce and toppings were good but that crust was horrible. We paid over $60 for a pizza, a Greek salad and a small order of chicken bites.
We ordered 2 extra large pizzas and they were excellent. The ordering process was easy and the people are awesome. We will order from them again.
I asked for no gorgonzola cheese but it was there, and I cannot eat it so I had to pick it out and was very difficult to get all the pieces out.
Fries were hot and good. cheessteak was good
Full Menu
Soft Drinks
Starters & Salads
Wraps
Salads
Small Plates
Entree
More information
QR-code link to the menu
