Cousin Vinny's Pizza - Middletown

By far the best pizza place in Middletown! The staff is ALWAYS friendly and the pizza always comes really fast, even on Friday or Saturday nights. I can't say enough about this place. Donatos is my favorite pizza, but the Middletown Donatos is garbage because of her staff. Rude in the core. I'm so glad I found cousin Vinnys!! You are the best

Approved by a foodie! The Sausage Baked Ziti was amazing. It had a rich flavor that set it apart from the typical, low-quality pasta dishes you find at most pizza places. This was genuinely delicious! The brownie was also excellent, and I usually don't have a sweet tooth. Great job, Vinnie's!

As always, the food is incredible. This is my favorite pizza place to order from. I always get the cheese bread, and it never disappoints. I tried the chicken Philly sandwich for the first time and was astounded by how delicious it was. What I appreciate most about Cousin Vinny's is that you really get your money's worth. I've been to many pizza places, but none can compare to Cousin Vinny's, which, in my opinion, uses the freshest ingredients of all the pizza places I've ever tried.

The pizza and salad were excellent! I will definitely order again. The delivery took about 30 minutes. Thank you for the fantastic service!

This is hands down some of the most adventurous pizza I've ever tasted! The delightful bread and massive biscuits are absolutely scrumptious as well. I've ordered from here many times and will definitely continue to do so in the future. The prices are reasonable considering the exceptional quality of the food.