Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Kinsey's Italian Cafe:
I had the Alfredo with spinach and mushrooms and it was delicious. The garlic knots were also very good. The server was great, I highly recommend this affordable restaurant! View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Kinsey's Italian Cafe:
I ordered a sub from the restaurant with high hopes of getting a decent sandwich, something that is hard to come by in Indiana. Unfortunately, the meat was lacking and the sandwich was drowned in salad. Additionally, the staff put it in a pocket instead of wrapping it properly, resulting in a messy eating experience. Overall, the quality of the sandwich did not meet my expectations. View all feedback.
That will be lunch. salat very good, but I never have the chance to experience a piece of pizza. after I enjoy my salad. pizza is gone. I waited for the next pizza, I noticed that the server on the table behind us told a table of 4 people that she brought out a fresh pizza. they took every slice. I will not come back. $9.95 for tee and salate was ridiculous.
We drive almost an hour from Muncie to eat here, always fresh and authentic Italian! The staff is amazing, and makes you feel like family!! This is the only place I go for authentic Italian food, and I tell everyone I can about this place! The portions are huge and the garlic knots are to die for!
I have had “good” calzone and Stromboli but this place takes it to a whole new level of outstanding!Friendly prompt service, reasonable prices. This place is a hidden gem!
They serve generous and flavorful portions of their entrees. My favorite is lasagna which is really good. Also with a side of garlic knots.
Authentic Italian cuisine, great staff makes you feel welcome. This is my go to place for Italian period!! I drive almost an hour to eat here!
Full Menu
Mexican-American Food
Pasta
More information
QR-code link to the menu
