Captain Charlie's Reef Grill

Hole in the wall local place with incredible seafood and great service. If you know... you know....

We were so impressed we ate here 2 of the 4 nights in town. Everything was fantastic. From the wine list to the best ice cream we have ever had. It was chewy, how do you even make chewy ice cream? They should call it Al dente homemade ice cream. Baked oysters, best we have ever had. The rigatoni with shrimp and scallops in a Gorgonzola sauce, unbelievable. We have already decided we would vacation again in the area just to eat here. We met a couple that has eaten here 32 nights in a row now and tried something new each night. Service is top notch too. Go and enjoy! Sit at the bar if you can and watch all the creations come together in front of you.

From paella to seafood dishes and Italian to fresh fish, this place packs in a TON of flavor and so much talent in the kitchen you won’t know what hit you! 5 stars, Captain Carlie!!!!

The food at this restaurant is consistently delicious, especially for seafood lovers.

This local diner is adorable. The fish I had was very fresh and the almond and cornflake breading was surprisingly delicious. The seafood broccoli cheese soup was flavorful but a bit watery. Overall, most of the dishes were somewhat bland. We ordered the seafood Mac and cheese but received a pasta with a plain pink sauce and only shrimp. It wasn't bad, but I was disappointed considering the rave reviews. I appreciate a cozy small restaurant, and this one was clean with friendly staff.