Images
ContributeNo images to show
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Melissa K likes about Natalie's Pizza:
Food and staff are AMAZING! I work in a school so when I have large orders and specific directions on food he takes care of us and they are always on time. Staff really work with us and our needs, doesn't matter if we do a last min order, and the food is delicious! My favorite is Buffalo chicken slice! View all feedback.
What Chilton Brown doesn't like about Natalie's Pizza:
Placed order at 7:56 on Slice app was advised 8:41 latest time for delivery 9:26 no pizza and restaurant is closed. I live literally 5 minutes away I will never order from here and will be requesting full refund View all feedback.
Great pizza , way better than Dominos and Papa John's.Food: 5/5
Placed order at 7:56 on Slice app was advised 8:41 latest time for delivery 9:26 no pizza and restaurant is closed. I live literally 5 minutes away I will never order from here and will be requesting full refund
This was my first time ordering pizza from here. I must say this is by far the best pizza in the neighborhood. The pizza was baked perfectly and it was delivered hot. Under 25 min delivery time!!!
Food was cold. Guy on the phone was super rude towards me. It was all so upsetting. Ambiance was disgusting
The pizza is good but they’ve upped their prices to Manhattan levels. Why would I pay Manhattan prices living in Jamaica hills?
More information
QR-code link to the menu
