Reviews
What Maximo Price doesn't like about Madeline's - Ithaca:
A meal was good. A meal was a lamb dish and it was delivered vegetarian?? A meal was Steak... Steak was good, but vegetables were cold and black. No discount was offered. I'd never go back. View all feedback. What Mable Kuphal likes about Madeline's - Ithaca:
Madeline's offers high-quality dining at a reasonable price. The service is excellent and the desserts are incredibly delicious. Dining outside on the patio during warm summer days is a delightful experience. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
We only stopped in to pick up some dessert (apparently a common tradition for college students), and they tasted good.
I came here the other night for drinks and dessert and had a genuinely lovely time.
New menu is interesting and has some good options. Eating was usually good, but cooking was very precise, e.g., medium rarely came out as rare, dirty Martini wi...
read moreThe server seemed a bit distracted and slow during our dining experience. Despite only a few tables in the restaurant, we had to wait longer than expected betwe...
read moreEven though I live 350 miles away, Madeline is one of my favorite restaurants. I was excited to bring some city friends to try it out and they really enjoyed it...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreMadeline's restaurant offers a fine dining experience at an affordable price, making it a favorite for many. The new menu has interesting options, however, the cooking can be hit or miss. Despite some issues with precision in cooking, the service is usually good, with knowledgeable servers who can recommend from the menu. The desserts are a highlight and dining outside in the summer adds to the charm of the experience. While some guests may have experienced slow service or disappointing dishes, Madeline's remains a popular choice for those looking for a special dining experience at a reasonable price.