Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Mike Reilly likes about Peyton's Pie Company:
Just a casual date night stop, it was delicious food and an inviting staff. Shared a salad and the SFI pizza, both remarkable! I had their pizza a long while back when they were in Suwanee, it 's only gotten better. This is not for your discount pizza fan, this is for the foodie pizza lover. A nice combination between Neopolitan and NY. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 View all feedback.
What Greg Simpson doesn't like about Peyton's Pie Company:
The pizza was good but our server rushed us as soon as we were seated. We arrived about 7:50 and they stay open till 9pm. She rushed us to order , when asked why she said they were about to run out of somethings. I noticed they turned away people before 9pm. I am not very happy about how we were treated. Who wants to spend money at a restaurant where it seems they want to push you out the door.Vegetarian options: The... View all feedback.
Been there twice now. I wish I took some pics, but I will for the next time I go. : I have had the SFC and the Margherita pizzas. Both were awesome. The SFC is pricey but damn it was yummy. The greasy new yorker is great as well. I love the crust, airy and light and crispy. I count Peytons in my top 3 pizza places. Definitely worth trying out if your in flowery branch area. Service has always been good as well. There is not a lot of seating but well worth the wait. 10/13/2023 Peytons still rocking the awesome pizza in flowery branch GA. Has the Seahorse and it was great. The peppedews add just the right amount of sweet heat. Their weekly pizza was a salmon pie. Very good as well. I highly recommend both. :
Just a casual date night stop, it was delicious food and an inviting staff. Shared a salad and the SFI pizza, both remarkable! I had their pizza a long while back when they were in Suwanee, it 's only gotten better. This is not for your discount pizza fan, this is for the foodie pizza lover. A nice combination between Neopolitan and NY. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30
Great pizza with a cool vibe brewery next door. Fast service, too. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4
This is my favorite pizzeria when I'm in town and I want a place with a nice atmosphere, good service and delicious pizza. Thank you people. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
The pie was delicious, ask for extra crispy and you can thank me later. Ashley (server) has an amazing personality and work ethic.
Full Menu
Mexican-American Food
Dessert
Toppings
More information
QR-code link to the menu
