Reviews
What User likes about Old Chicago Pizza Taproom:
First time having Old Chicago. Ordered the 8 slice Detroit style pizza and it was ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! Super crispy crust, great sauce and cheese was melted perfectly. My new go to when in Fayetteville! View all feedback. What Juan R doesn't like about Old Chicago Pizza Taproom:
This is a really great place to hang out, have a beer, and watch the game. Ordered a margarita, meatballs, and two pizzas. Meatballs tasted cold in some parts while the sauce was hot. We sent the appetizer back and got mozzarella sticks;perfect. Pizzas are well-portioned with good flavor. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Our waitress really cool! The bartender was on point, our pizza was good and fresh as always! We Old Chicago and will return SOON!
First time having Old Chicago. Ordered the 8 slice Detroit style pizza and it was ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! Super crispy crust, great sauce and cheese was melted perf...
read moreThe mushroom appetizer was amazing. Even better but similar to Outbacks blooming onion. That used to be my favorite food. After tonight that shifted. Will be or...
read moreFirst time was a really good experience. Our food was delicious, hot and fresh. I ordered the crafted beer burger and it was great. Our waitress was nice and fr...
read moreThis was our first visit to Old Chicago. Upon arrival the restaurant only had one other table. The restaurant filled up quickly. Our server was good but seemed...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreOld Chicago offers a vibrant atmosphere perfect for sports fans and casual diners. While the menu features standout items like the Detroit-style pizza and Italian nachos, diners have reported mixed experiences with pizza quality and consistency in service. Some dishes, like the meatballs and wings, left much to be desired. Nevertheless, the attentive staff and friendly ambiance have garnered praise. With reasonable pricing, impressive beer selection, and rewarding specials, Old Chicago remains a popular choice for those seeking a lively dining experience, though patrons are advised to choose their dishes wisely.
We've been here a few times on weekdays shortly after they've opened at 11 a.m. and it's not crowded then. Lots of TV screens with different sports events going...
read moreFirst time ordering from here but I had a taste for some chicken parm. Size is generous, price is reasonable. I ordered online and picked it up to go. I was gre...
read morePizza Rate (Cauliflower): 6.1. Awesome selection of beers. Plenty of appetizers options and All American food. The customer service was very good.
This is a really great place to hang out, have a beer, and watch the game. Ordered a margarita, meatballs, and two pizzas. Meatballs tasted cold in some parts w...
read moreAte here for the first time yesterday and was honestly very disappointed. The wings were not very good and the pizza is maybe a 5/10 at most. We were expecting...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe food was great! My mom and I went there and I ordered the craft your own Mac and cheese, which was delicious and I highly recommend it. My mom ordered the I...
read moreMy family and I absolutely love Old Chicago!! I used to work at one in Colorado and loved it! Yesterday we went to eat for my husbands bday and the service was...
read moreAte there first time today Food was fantastic.Our waiter Derrick was the best. Will definitely visit again. Thanks
Just gave our waiter a $20 tip... The color of his nor our skin mattered.... our political views didn't matter... how much or little money either party had didn...
read moreThe gf crust tasted good and I really enjoyed the fresh basil on my pizza. It really brings the freshness to the meal.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe Bavarian pretzel sticks and craft your own calzone were both delicious. The boneless wings had good flavor, but were overpriced for the portion size. Unfort...
read moreThey put some time and care into their food. Pizza is great thick crust very good sausage is insane. Mac and cheese is quite comforting.
The Italian nachos were delicious, with just the right amount of ingredients. The kids' pizza meal was also excellent, even better than the regular adult-sized...
read moreThe Jalapeño Pretzel Bites were slightly overcooked but the sauce helped salvage it. I would rate it a 3 out of 10. The restaurant provided plenty of sauce for...
read moreThe Thai Pie is delicious! One of the best tasting foods Ive yet eaten. Definitely recommend.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more