Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Daniel Sclafani likes about Carlo's Gourmet Pizzeria, Caterers:
Amazing experience! From the moment I called to place my order, the staff's energy on the phone was top-notch. My order was ready when I arrived, thanks to the friendly staff. The food was delicious, especially the large calzone that I shared with my partner. I couldn't even take a picture of it because it was so good! They offer gluten-free options, but since I love gluten, I didn't check them out. The parking right... View all feedback.
What DemetrioQuintoAmog doesn't like about Carlo's Gourmet Pizzeria, Caterers:
Pizzas aight. A bit dry especially the chicken and that includes the Chicken Parmigiana. Also don't go by ETA. I went in 5 minutes before ETA and was lukewarm at best. Also, when I went to pick up all I was handed was the Chicken Parmigiana. Took the person a few minutes to look back and realize I had pizzas as well. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner View all feedback.
I am pregnant and I felt guilty calling multiple times for my order being incorrect. However, their customer service is truly exceptional and the staff is extremely kind!
The new owners appear to be friendly. I only tried a slice of pizza, so I can't comment on the overall food quality, but the pizza lacked flavor. It had too little sauce for my preference.
The food was average, but the prices were quite high. We paid $60 for two pizzas with vegetable toppings, which seemed excessive. The markup was excessive! The pizza was mediocre, but we appreciated that they allowed for takeaway orders and had gluten-free options available.
I typically enjoy the food at this restaurant, but my experience with the gluten-free chicken parm was disappointing. The chicken was extremely thin and overcooked, almost splintering. The sauce on the pasta was watery and running off. It was a shame that we drove all the way from Eatontown for the food. I'm not sure if we'll make that trip again. This used to be my go-to spot for gluten-free Italian food, but after giving it another chance on October 2nd, I was thoroughly disappointed. The pasta was undercooked, the sauce was unappetizing, and the meatballs were rubbery and lacked flavor. The gluten-free garlic bread was simply a toasted hot dog roll for $10. It was a horrible experience and I will not be returning. I recommend anyone in need of gluten-free options to look for another restaurant.
Amazing experience! From the moment I called to place my order, the staff's energy on the phone was top-notch. My order was ready when I arrived, thanks to the friendly staff. The food was delicious, especially the large calzone that I shared with my partner. I couldn't even take a picture of it because it was so good! They offer gluten-free options, but since I love gluten, I didn't check them out. The parking right in front of the store was convenient as well.