D'agostino's Pizzeria Inc. - Depew

I'm a pretty big pizza. Snob. Sauce is good, little bit sweet but that pairs well with the pepperoni which was excellent. The dough seemed a little, underdone. Perhaps? A little chewy. I would like to have a bit more crisp on the very bottom as well. Looks fantastic. I was a little bit disappointed with the garlic bread. As it's just a sub roll. The flavor was good, but I want real garlic bread. Sub roll does not have the texture of good Italian

D'Agostino's is my favorite place to get a pizza. I'm very picky when it comes to pizza, but their semi-sweet sauce and mild smokey pepperoni is just so good. I've been ordering from them since I was a kid.

I have been a customer of D'Agostino's Pizzeria since I was a teenager. They are among my absolute favorites. I'm very picky where my pizza is concerned, especially in regard to the sauce. The sweetness and acidity needs to be perfectly balanced, which theirs certainly is. Oh, and the crust. When I ask for extra crispy crust, I want extra crispy. And I really hate when my pepperoni is too spicy. They never fail to disappoint. Truly excellent!

The food was good. I'm not a huge pizza snob but there are standards that I have and this pizza meets them! The wings are a good size and have great flavor, are cooked perfect! Moist in the middle and fully cooked skin. The people working there were super nice and had the food ready on time. The price cannot be beat! Not sure how I am just finding out about this place as I've been going to the sushi place next door for at least 5 years now... so glad I found my new go to!!!

Great pizza, great staff and service. If you haven't tried their pizza give it a shot you won't be disappointed.