Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria:
The service was excellent and the food was great, they really impressed us! It's a really charming restaurant. Two of us had two large sandwiches for $20. We forgot to take photos, sorry. View all feedback.
What Rebekah Lee doesn't like about Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria:
I called 20 minutes before they were closing to place a takeout order, but they answered the phone saying they were already closed. The service, food, and atmosphere all received a rating of 1. View all feedback.
Pizza and breadsticks were excellent, quick delivery.
Amazing customer service when I walked in and such great pizza! I had the chicken alfredo as well as the taco specialties. I am blown away at how fresh it is. Quality ingredients, presentation, and I feel great after eating it and not weighed down like with other pizzas. I'll definitely order again. Thanks!
I love thin crust pizza and this place does it right! Awesome service and friendly staff too.
Yesterday we went to this good restaurant for the first time. But... it is certainly not the last. We had great time with the courtesy service, with the finest food and alcohol and with the honest price. We will return there in no time.
We arrived 40 minutes before closing. The restaurant was invalid for customers. The atmosphere was pleasant. The staff was pleasant and accommodating. My main goal for the visit was to get a hot fudge malt. In my opinion, Papa Jimmy's is in the top 2, for the best tasting, high quality malt, in Madison and surroundings. THE MALT WAS PERFECT! Excellent taste and consistency. We decided to order a handcuffed pizza with 5 kinds of meat. ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Thanks to Joe and Papa Jimmy's staff for their commitment to customer satisfaction and Exellence.
Full Menu
American Food
Pasta
Pizza
Toppings
Sauces
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-code link to the menu
