Tomatoes Ii Pizzeria - Feedback

I get a bacon, egg, and provolone on buttered/ toasted Italian bread. Cooked fresh, right in front of you. Huge sandwich for the money. Best breakfast sandwich... read more I get a bacon, egg, and provolone on buttered/ toasted Italian bread. Cooked fresh, right in front of you. Huge sandwich for the money. Best breakfast sandwich in Pittsburgh!

Ordered a cheese pizza and mozzarella sticks are the best I had and the service is also really good. Definitely gonna recommend a lot of my friends read more Ordered a cheese pizza and mozzarella sticks are the best I had and the service is also really good. Definitely gonna recommend a lot of my friends

I was trying late night to get Pizza from my favorite place in town that doesn’t deliver and couldn’t figure it out for the life of me… That’s when I saw Tomato... read more I was trying late night to get Pizza from my favorite place in town that doesn’t deliver and couldn’t figure it out for the life of me… That’s when I saw Tomatoes II PiZzeriA.. It was 1 minute before closing and I put in a Pepperoni Pizza order (I know, I was THAT guy). I called in to make sure it was ok, and the staff couldn’t be nicer… I couldn’t believe that this dude brought it over himself, fixed a price issue with the third party ordering service and have me a free drink (I should have just called).. Amazing service, AND I HAVE A NEW FAVORITE PIZZA IN TOWN!

Tomato's II Pizzeria in Pittsburgh offers a delightful array of classic comfort foods, including wings, pizza, and cheese sticks. The wings are crispy on the ou... read more Tomato's II Pizzeria in Pittsburgh offers a delightful array of classic comfort foods, including wings, pizza, and cheese sticks. The wings are crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside, with a variety of flavorful sauces to choose from. The pizza is generously topped with fresh ingredients and baked to perfection, boasting a deliciously crispy crust. The cheese sticks are a crowd-pleaser, with gooey cheese oozing out of a golden-brown crust. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, perfect for a casual meal. Overall, Tomato's II Pizzeria provides a satisfying dining experience with friendly service and tasty food.

I really enjoyed the Pizza and subs at Tomatoes II in Carnegie. I am always on the prowl for the best pizza in Pittsburgh and this place is a gem. Also the owne... read more I really enjoyed the Pizza and subs at Tomatoes II in Carnegie. I am always on the prowl for the best pizza in Pittsburgh and this place is a gem. Also the owner and his wife were super kind and helpful. Highly recommend.

Great pizza, and wings too. I enjoy supporting this local business. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner read more Great pizza, and wings too. I enjoy supporting this local business. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner

First time in this place. Ordered a small pizza and a Philly steak sandwich. According to the menu board the pizza 7.99 and the steak 8.99 with a bottle of Diet... read more First time in this place. Ordered a small pizza and a Philly steak sandwich. According to the menu board the pizza 7.99 and the steak 8.99 with a bottle of Diet Pepsi I was 29.80. The Philly did not have any grilled mushrooms or onions or green peppers. The owner was there and he said this menu board is 14 years old. I offered to pay them when I placed the order but they refused, they said: you pay when your food is ready. What a way to hustle and connive people. He said we depend on online orders not on walk ins. The mayor of Carnegie should go and have lunch there.

Don’t waste your money on this place, it’s bottom shelf!! Service: Delivery Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Dietary restrictions accommodated: Not su... read more Don’t waste your money on this place, it’s bottom shelf!! Service: Delivery Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Dietary restrictions accommodated: Not sure

Very long wait for order Service: Delivery Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 read more Very long wait for order Service: Delivery Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100

I had a very disappointing experience at this restaurant, mainly due to the manager's unbelievable attitude. Even though pasta was listed on the menu, they refu... read more I had a very disappointing experience at this restaurant, mainly due to the manager's unbelievable attitude. Even though pasta was listed on the menu, they refused to prepare it, saying it was too hot. I found this completely unreasonable, as water boils at 212 degrees, and they use much higher temperatures for dishes like pizza and fried wings. If they are unable to serve a menu item, they should simply take it off the menu. I would rate the food, service, and atmosphere all a 1 out of 10.

Tomatoes II pizza in Carnegie is good pizza. The crust is awesome and the sauce is not overwhelmingly sweet. Garlic knots, pepperoni puffs and the cinnamon suga... read more Tomatoes II pizza in Carnegie is good pizza. The crust is awesome and the sauce is not overwhelmingly sweet. Garlic knots, pepperoni puffs and the cinnamon sugar puffs were all delicious.

We've eaten here a handful of times over the years. Unfortunately, after this most recent order we'll probably take our business elsewhere. When we called and p... read more We've eaten here a handful of times over the years. Unfortunately, after this most recent order we'll probably take our business elsewhere. When we called and placed the order, we were told our total. Upon picking up and paying, they changed us anadditional 80 cents, different from what they told us our total would be. We were told this was a fee for paying with a creditcard. You gotta be transparent with your customers. Oh, and the garlic knots had no flavor. The pizza had little to no sauce.

Owners are so nice and attentive. Any issues I?ve ever had have been reassured with great customer service. staff is always nice and thoughtful. Great food too! read more Owners are so nice and attentive. Any issues I?ve ever had have been reassured with great customer service. staff is always nice and thoughtful. Great food too!

Went there about 4 weeks ago and didn't feel good afterwards. Wasn't ready to blame anyone. But got a hogie and wings 2 days ago and ended up in St. Clair hospi... read more Went there about 4 weeks ago and didn't feel good afterwards. Wasn't ready to blame anyone. But got a hogie and wings 2 days ago and ended up in St. Clair hospital with food poisoning. Only thing I ate all day, so there is no doubt it was from there food.STAY AWAY!

I tried it today for the first time and everything I got was good pizza wings and a hoagie plus the price wasn't outrageous like some other places around I will... read more I tried it today for the first time and everything I got was good pizza wings and a hoagie plus the price wasn't outrageous like some other places around I will be back to try more soon keep up the good work

This was my first time ordering from here. I tried the breaded mushrooms, which were delicious, accompanied by a flavorful marinara sauce. I also had a pepperon... read more This was my first time ordering from here. I tried the breaded mushrooms, which were delicious, accompanied by a flavorful marinara sauce. I also had a pepperoni pizza with a thin crust. It was very tasty, featuring great flavors in the sauce and perfectly golden brown cheese. My partner ordered the chicken Parmesan, which looked amazing. We both enjoyed our meals thoroughly. The service was quick, and the food was served hot. Great job, everyone! I’ll definitely be ordering from you again.