Full menu with prices & pictures
Mike Cathy's Good Ol... W995 W North Shore Dr, Montello, 539...
+19202956358
Reserve a table now for Mike Cathy's Good Ol...
Here you can find the menu of Mike Cathy's Good Old Days in Montello. At the moment, there are 16 courses and drinks on the menu.
What Kathleen Gusloff likes about Mike Cathy's Good Old Days:
Our family loves the fish and chicken on Fridays. You can also get baked cod if you are gluten free. Comes with baked beans, Cole slaw, German potato salad, and or broasted potatoes. Delish! View all feedback.
What Rebecca Smith doesn't like about Mike Cathy's Good Old Days:
Bartender was johnny on the spot; wait staff not so much. Slow to take our order and even slower to bring our bill. We are not prime rib lovers so we both had boneless ribeye. Neither of our steaks were particularly tender for a ribeye. Salad bar was just ok. High point was the mushroom soup. It was excellent. Also we were seated in the added on porch and it was very warm in the room. I was sitting there and sweating... View all feedback.
If I could do below 1 star I would have this place was the absolute worse. My husband and I cam...
Went there for the all you can eat fish and chicken with 10 people 4 adults 6 kids. Server firs...
Bartender wouldn't allow service dog in with veteran. Took our business to Log Cabin Resort and...
Bartender was johnny on the spot; wait staff not so much. Slow to take our order and even slowe...
We tried the Friday fish fry and it was awesome. It came with German potato salad, coleslaw, ry...