Full menu with prices & pictures
New Sheffield Cafe 2211 Sheffield Rd, 15001, Aliquippa,...
+17243755680
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for New Sheffield Cafe
The restaurant from Aliquippa offers 19 different dishes and drinks on the card at an average price of $1.5.
Located in a lively neighborhood, this restaurant is a beloved spot for locals, offering a diverse menu that includes standout burgers, gyros, and chicken salads. Guests appreciate the friendly and welcoming atmosphere, complemented by excellent service and a good selection of cold beers. While some have noted that portion sizes can vary, many find the dishes satisfying and delicious, particularly praising the rice pilaf and freshly cooked bread. Despite some parking challenges at the new location, the overall dining experience, highlighted by home-cooked flavors and generous portions, keeps patrons returning for more culinary delights.
What User likes about New Sheffield Cafe:
The first time for early dinner. We had the Bret's Special and Gyro. Service overall was great. The salad was not great. The beer was cold, but no frost cups. According to my guest, the Gyro was very good. My Bret's special had three over boiled meat steak, chicken and shrimp. The rice pilaf was excellent. The bread was also excellent. The Pommes were very good. Overall, the meal was good, but not great. I'd go back... View all feedback.
What Dennis C doesn't like about New Sheffield Cafe:
I ordered a chicken tender salad for dinner tonight. I was very disappointed with the portion size - only 3 olives, 8 pieces of cheese, and chicken that seemed more suitable for a child. View all feedback.
The first time for early dinner. We had the Bret's Special and Gyro. Service overall was great....
Great food and generous portions. that has been a home city lover of my family for years. beaut...
Great neighborhood place to eat...so friendly and welcoming. Great food... not your average bar...
The problem I had with the new sheffield Cafe in its new location is the parking is horrible!!...
Great food, good prices, and service is extremely good. Can’t wait to come back.