Full menu with prices & pictures
Jimmy Hays Steak Hou... Island Park, NY 11558, 4310 Austin B...
+15164325155
Reserve a table now for Jimmy Hays Steak Hou...
What Val E likes about Jimmy Hays Steak House:
So delicious!!! I have to say this because every single time I go there omg I love everything, big amount of food so usually I order to split my dishes with my partner because it is too much food but I love that! Recommend! View all feedback.
What Chris B doesn't like about Jimmy Hays Steak House:
Not as good as I was hoping and remembered from 10 years ago. Apps we're good, dozen raw clams, baked clams, cheese bread, crab cakes (tiny serving . Steaks were only just ok though. Cowboy ribeye was way under-seasoned, only a C+ on the sear and cook (2 inch thick ribeye, mid-rare came out with what appeared to be an A+ sear, but was really just 1/4 inch outer layer overcooked and then extremely rare inside. Everyon... View all feedback.
Our waiter Rory was rude and arrogant and marginalized our entire experience. Food was ok
No masks, nothing distancing! Two dollar signs? Try ten dollar signs! Food okay, staff nice. Ma...
0nly valet parking why? No handicap parking. Dinner excellent.
My buddy and I had reservations for Peter Luger’s but after playing golf all day in Oceanside w...
Great atmosphere.... great service… awesome food and the McCluskeys Sundae alone is worth the t...